Friday, October 14, 2016

Taming the Untamable and Childhood Nostalgia

While we were talking about Jewel's special relationship with his prized horse, I couldn't help but think back to a very old cartoon I watched when I was younger, called Spirit: Stallion of the Cimarron. It was made in 2002 by Dreamworks, and I absolutely loved it. Evidently I wasn't the only one to feel that way: it was nominated for the Academy Award for Best Animated Feature and earned $122.6 million on a $80 million dollar budget. But enough of its achievements for now, back on why Spirit and As I lay Dying have some super similar scenes/ motifs.

So, the idea of "taming the beast" is a very classic action in a hero's journey. Sometimes it's relatively easy, but more often than not it's quite difficult. It can range from taming giant monsters or tending to fearsome/ unruly animals. Lots of examples come to mind: Owen Grady taming the pack of velociraptors in the most recent Jurassic Park, Belle teaching manners to the Beast in The Beauty and the Beast, or Hiccup taming Toothless in How to Tame your Dragon. In our particular cases however, the fearsome beast that's trying to be tamed is a little bit more down to Earth: the horse.

Spirit: Stallion of the Cimarron is an animated American western film that follows the adventures of a young mustang stallion living in the 19th century wild west. At this time, the U.S. army is fighting the indian wars and taking over the soon-to-be western united states. There's a lot of plot I could get into, but for the sake of not spoiling the movie in case you haven't seen it/ keeping things relevant to the taming of horses, I'll jump around. Spirit is captured by the U.S. army, who happen to be the antagonists in this movie, to be used in the U.S. calvary. "The Colonel", one of the head honchos of the calvary, tries to tame him but fails *miserably*, since Spirit is a very violent and very rebellious horse. Meanwhile, a Lakota Native American named Little Creek has also been captured and has been brought to the same calvary post as Spirit. A series of events occur, and with Little Creek's help, Spirit is able to escape the post with a bunch of other horses. Here's where the actual taming begins.

Back at the Lakota village, Little Creek first tries to tame Spirit with kindness. Spirit, being the fiercely independent soul he is, still refuses to be ridden. Little Creek tries a large variety of tactics: bribery with massive amounts of apples (which spirit loves), trickery with a fancy quilt, and even wooing Spirit with a mare. However, all of these tactics prove to be relatively useless and Spirit remains as rough and rowdy as ever, until through a series of very interesting events Spirit finally yields and allows Little Creek to ride him. These taming scenes feel astonishingly similar to Jewel and his horse; both horses are unruly and very untamed until much later on, forced through many unpleasant situations. Both of the tamers of these "beasts" have an affinity for animals, sometimes treating them even better than the humans around them. Overall I just think it's pretty neat to see such a similar kind of relationship in two completely different story arcs. Highly recommend watching Spirit: Stallion of the Cimarron if you haven't seen it btw! It might be 14 years old now but I still really like it!

5 comments:

  1. I haven't seen the movie but I agree that this "taming the beat" type of situation is pretty common and you can apply it to a lot of things. George Romero even has a film where they manage to sort of "tame" the zombies and get them to eat something other than people. And this is somewhat lacking in relevance but I think it's just as fun an interesting to watch a character struggle to tame a beat within themselves as it is to watch a character train a to-be companion beat. So I'm kind of disappointed we haven't come across that, but with the type of literature we're looking at I'm not sure we will find any examples of taming an inner beat.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I haven't seen the movie but I agree that this "taming the beat" type of situation is pretty common and you can apply it to a lot of things. George Romero even has a film where they manage to sort of "tame" the zombies and get them to eat something other than people. And this is somewhat lacking in relevance but I think it's just as fun an interesting to watch a character struggle to tame a beat within themselves as it is to watch a character train a to-be companion beat. So I'm kind of disappointed we haven't come across that, but with the type of literature we're looking at I'm not sure we will find any examples of taming an inner beat.

    ReplyDelete
  3. First things first: yes, this is an AWESOME movie and everyone should watch it! Anyway, I agree that these two narratives are definitely reminiscent of each other, and their differences help to really bring out what's important in each case. With Spirit, the main goal is to liberate Spirit from the bad-guy U.S. personnel. With As I Lay Dying, Jewel's goal is to have a companion and friend in this horse who only responds well to him. Thus, Little Creek releasing Spirit in the end is very different and much less tragic than Anse trading Jewel's horse away, since Jewel worked hard to earn and break his horse.

    ReplyDelete
  4. This post made me realize why the interactions between Jewel and his horse are probably my favorite parts of this book. As shown by the movie, it is fun to watch this kind of "taming the beast" narrative, which makes these scenes stand out from the other less fun to read parts of this book.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I also agree that Jewel's release of his horse was more tragic. Little Creek (I assume) had friends and family in his tribe, and for him Spirit was just another friend he wanted to do right by. Jewel definitely has a family, but he hardly interacts with them and they don't get along. Jewel's horse is really his only friend, and the one thing that he personally owns (living with one's parents at the age of around 22 would grate on anyone). Giving up the horse was basically giving up the only thing that was Jewel's

    ReplyDelete